Showing posts with label bank. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bank. Show all posts

Saturday, 13 February 2016

Lloyds Bank ECNs and Wild West UK

I have written before about Lloyds Bank, the Enhanced Capital Notes (ECNs) offered to more than 123,000 retail investors in exchange for their perpetual preference shares and former building society PIBS at the end of 2009.  Here's a detailed summary by Mark Taber.

The Financial Services Authority and Lloyds developed this new type of investment as a way to help the bank on the path to independence from government assistance after the financial crisis, saving the bank and taxpayers a significant sum of money.

ECNs were offered in a prospectus, which was put together under rules and regulations and approved by the FSA.

Antonio Horta Osorio joined Lloyds Banking Group as CEO in 2011.  In late 2014 Lloyds Bank announced that they planned to redeem the ECNs early, stating that this had been triggered by a stress test and was in line with a clause in the prospectus.  Nothing in the prospectus indicated that a right to redeem had been triggered and experienced lawyers agreed.




Retail customers approached the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), successor to the FSA, asking for protection.  The FCA declined and suggested that retail investors should deal with the issue in court.




In May 2015 the Chancellor of the High Court judged that Lloyds Bank did not have the right to redeem ECNs early.  Lloyds Bank claimed in the court that they made a mistake in drafting the early redemption clause in the prospectus and that the court should apply a different meaning to what was written.  The bank had never mentioned this error in the prospectus from 2009 until the court case in May 2015.  The FCA was not aware of it until retail investors notified them during the court proceedings.

The Court of Appeal allowed Lloyds Bank's appeal in December 2015 despite lengthy disagreements and arguments between learned counsel.  The 'mistake' was described as a 'drafting error' which all but the most naive investor should have understood.  Effectively the judgement stated that a contract as written can be changed later in court to suit the organisation that drafted it.  'A verbal contract isn't worth the paper it's written on' becomes 'a written contract is an approximation of the legal agreement you've signed.'




In late January 2016 the Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, announced a delay to the sale of government owned Lloyds Bank shares until after Easter 2016, because the share market has dropped in the banking sector.

Lloyds Bank then set 9 February 2016 as the date to redeem the ECNs, despite a request from investors for an appeal to the Supreme Court.  The Supreme Court ruled on 8 February 2016 that an appeal by retail investors would be allowed.  This was an unusually fast decision.  Neither the FCA nor the government intervened to delay redemption of the ECNs by the bank and Lloyds has now automatically redeemed these at par.  The appeal will be heard by the Supreme Court on 21 March 2016.  If retail investors win then compensation will be decided by Lloyds Bank.  Other costs, such as increased tax, may not be included.  

The Wild West has come to the UK, as we can no longer rely on the government or financial regulators to uphold regulations and protection for market stability and retail investors, even though this is part of their stated remit.  Organisations with enough money to go to court can make a contract with reasonable terms and then have them overturned in a court of law, arguing that any fool should have known they would have disadvantaged the organisation and were not intended as written.  




Members of the Treasury Select Committee have challenged Lloyds, but they have little power or influence when the regulators and the Chancellor seem determined to focus on national finances rather than the legal and regulatory framework of the UK.  Now our only hope seems to be in the hands of Mark Taber and the Supreme Court.  Perhaps there are still judges and lawyers who understand the risk and future consequences of a decision in favour of Lloyds Bank over its ECN prospectus. 





 

Thursday, 7 January 2016

Co-op Bank drops ethics

I've blogged many times about the crisis at the Co-op Bank in 2013-14 and attempts to plug their £3.6 billion funding gap by scalping bond and preference shareholders.  This was blocked by Mark Taber and the 3 US hedge funds with a controlling stake in the bank.




Aurelius Capital Management, Beach Point Capital Management, Silver Point Capital effectively owned the Co-op Bank, with their 80% stake, and sought to change the way it worked.  The bank offloaded non-core assets, cut stuff numbers by 21%, closed 62 branches, embarked on a membership drive and fundraising campaign.  Remaining branches have had a face lift and no doubt they are being dragged into the modern world with new computer systems.

One of the components of the drive for new customers was the assurance of their ethical standpoint, one of the major selling points throughout the Co-op Bank's history.




Now we discover that this 'ethical policy' includes closing accounts of humanitarian NGOs with no explanation to account holders.  Cuba Solidarity Campaign, Palestine Solidarity Campaign, Friends of Al-Aqsa accounts and others have been closed.  Co-op spokespeople have released statements to the media about 'risk management' and organisations not meeting their standards for due diligence and sending money to certain countries.  None of this was discussed with the organisations concerned, nor negotiations on how they might reach this vague 'standard'.  Presumably the bank is referring to UK money laundering regulations (which seem to be regularly forgotten when high net worth individuals from overseas suddenly want to buy UK property.)



'Such vulture funds are as far from the ideals of the Co-operative Group’s founding fathers as could be imagined.  Where those Rochdale cobblers and cabinetmakers joined together 170 years ago for social equity through mutual ownership of their enterprises, the likes of Aurelius and Silver Point aggressively aim to enrich the few at the expense of the many.'


Various groups plan to take legal action against the bank using equality legislation.  There is no guarantee that they will succeed, given Lloyds Bank's recent success in claiming immunity from prosecution over a prospectus, by arguing that customers 'should have known what they meant to write'.

People seem surprised at the actions of Co-op Bank.  I am not.




Aurelius Capital Management is run by Mark Brodsky, a lawyer formerly employed by Elliott Associates (one of the companies owned by Paul Singer, the notoriously aggressive vulture capitalist).  Aurelius CM (together with Elliott Associates) is attempting to force the government of Argentina to pay $1.3bn following the Argentinian debt default.  Elliott was behind the firm that bought Comet and quietly moved capital offshore before leaving it to fail (and the UK taxpayer to pick up the bill for redundancies).  Paul Singer is openly acknowledged to be pro-Zionist.

'Journalist Greg Palast said their tactics resembled “negotiating while holding the pin of the grenade”.'

The aspect of this that surprises me is the wailing by liberal left-wingers in this country.  They seem astonished by the change in the Co-op bank, but unwilling to move their accounts.  If you keep your money with vulture capitalists, then you support and endorse their activities.  Happily Oxford University students still seem to have their brains switched on after the closure of their PSC account.





Monday, 30 March 2015

Lloyds Bank CEO £11.5 million bonus

I have written before about Lloyds Bank's attempts to cheat bondholders out of their savings.  The case is now likely to be determined in court.  I wrote to the CEO, MPs and regulators.  I have yet to receive a reply from Mr António Horta-Osório.  

Today we hear that the Chief Executive is in line for a £11.5 million bonus.  It has to be agreed at the annual meeting on 14 May.




The bank has sacked 50,000 members of staff and now boasts a rising share price (after years of zero dividends for shareholders.)  As one investor points out, the rise in share price is due more to Quantitative Easing than his skill as a banker.  His bonus is paid in shares, so he is one of the biggest beneficiaries of the debasement of our currency.

I have seen a steady decline in the standard of retail service at Lloyds Bank.  I am unsure what the CEO thinks he has contributed to the bank during his time in post.  He had an extended period of leave because of stress, presumably on full pay.



I wonder what the unemployed former employees think about his value to the bank?

It seems that the Bank of England is out of synch with the European Banking Authority's ruling against top-up payments.  The EBA will issue formal guidelines on bonuses, with which all bank regulators in the EU must comply.  Andrew Bailey has argued against the fixed cap, saying it will force up fixed pay levels.  




Thursday, 26 March 2015

Lloyds Bank ECNs and 21st century Robin Hood

I've written before about Lloyds Bank and the attempt to boost its finances by redeeming ECNs.  These are a new financial instruments forced on bondholders when the bank was bailed out by the Treasury.  Lloyds plans to pay less than the going rate for ECNs.




Our modern Robin Hood is Mark Taber.  He voluntarily stepped in when bondholders were about to be fleeced by institutions such as Bank of Ireland (running Post Office banking) and the Co-operative Bank.  These banks decided that their customers could be pushed around.  Successive politicians have relaxed regulations on banks, so that they no longer depend on the relationship with retail customers and small investors, but generate more income from speculative investments.  The regulators ensure that the Treasury gets its money back with interest, but seem to ignore malpractice and actions on the edge of the law against customers.



Mark Taber has mounted campaigns to rally bondholders, worked tirelessly with banks and regulators behind the scenes and done what he can to ensure elderly savers and investors do not lose their savings when no one stands up to the City of London.  He does NOT steal from the rich, but helps protect the poor and those who were deceived into believing that banks would honour the contract they signed.

Today Mark Taber announced that a leading QC has studied the case and told him that Lloyd's plan to redeem the 'enhanced capital notes' for less than their market value had 'no proper basis for a redemption'.  Taber is seeking a 'declaratory judgement' in court, so that a decision is made in a contractual dispute before any action is taken.  The decision of the court is binding.

Court costs may affect the action, as Lloyds could claim £10 million + in legal fees.  This would be absurd if it applied to misselling of Payment Protection Insurance, for example, and should be ruled out in the instance too.

This is not limited to Lloyds Bank, but another financial institution is planning to pull the same stunt and would not hesitate to follow if Lloyds were allowed to proceed and effectively steal from its customers.



After my previous post, I wrote to the regulators, various MPs on the Treasury Select Committee and the Lloyds Bank CEO, António Horta-Osório.  I received standard replies from 2 of these people.  However from Lloyds Bank CEO - answer came there none.


Monday, 26 January 2015

Lloyds Bank Quaker Founders turning in their graves

Quakers and workers' groups are not much discussed in the UK these days.  They formed our banks, chocolate industry and established fixed priced, fair trading.  They based their dealings on ethics and integrity.  That was back in the 18th and 19th centuries.






Lloyds bank was one of these.


The bank suffered during the financial crisis and was bailed out by the government.  They were ordered to reduce the number of branches and split from TSB, which they'd acquired earlier.  Lloyds swapped bonds for ECNs or Enhanced Capital Notes:

'What are ECNs and CoCos?



ECNs stands for Enhanced Capital Notes. They are, somewhat confusingly also referred to as CoCos or Contingent Convertibles. ECNs are a new form of fixed income security which have arisen out of the need for banks to increase their capital ratios as a result of the banking crisis. The first UK issuer of ECN's has been Lloyds Banking Group plc. This was under an Exchange Offer announced on 3 November to exchange its existing Tier 1 and Upper Tier 2 securities into new ECN's.
The key feature of the Lloyds ECN's is that while they carry mandatory coupon rights they may also be mandatorily converted into ordinary shares if the Core Tier 1 capital ratio of the bank falls below the 5% level (known as the trigger).'

In December 2014 Lloyds Bank announced that they intended to redeem these ECNs for below face value, in order to raise money.  This affected elderly savers and investors, who did not understand what had happened, nor that Lloyds had the power to do this.  Here is one example of the effects of the move.

I have discussed the work of Mark Taber in previous posts about the Co-op Bank.  He has worked on behalf of bond and preference share holders of various banks, ensuring that they were fairly treated.  Mark worked on this voluntarily (although he accepts donations).




When Mark Taber takes up the fight, you know the situation is serious and that financial institutions have behaved badly.

In this case, it appears that government regulatory authorities did not include ECNs in financial instruments that were monitored, leaving customers unprotected.

Lloyds Bank made excuses and implied that investors were remiss when they didn't read about the move, rather than admitting that they kept quiet about the poor deal for ECN holders.

One serious allegation is that Lloyds Bank misdescribed the ECNs and their terms and conditions when they were first offered.  Lloyds also fudged the initial description and definition of ECNs with a simple omission and switch of terms.  Lloyds Bank are challenged on the legality of their action.

BBC's Money Box featured the news in this programme (13.30 minutes in).




Antonio Horta Osorio, Lloyds Bank CEO, has already had time off from the job through stress.  He and his team seem to be ignoring the real distress caused to investors in buying back ECNs at less than half the price.

I believe that the Quaker founders would not approve of this sleight of hand.




Experience from the Co-operative Bank's attempt to trash its core values was that all customers rejected it, not just the affected bondholders.  I still maintain that the only way is ethics.

Postscript:

The case is currently going through the courts.  Here is an interesting comment by one investor.

More Quakers are probably spinning in their graves at this news.


Saturday, 25 January 2014

NatWest Bank

When I first started in business, I spoke to managers of each of the clearing banks before deciding where to open an account for my business.

One guy looked like a spotty 15 year old.  When I asked about impact of the imminent EU englargement, he said:  "There's not much call for that sort of thing around here."

The second manager arrived late for our meeting, smelling as if he'd imbibed a rather large liquid lunch.  His response to my business plan was impassive.

The third man was a bit more business savvy, as his dad ran a fruit and veg market stall.

None of them appeared to have the skills to read a business plan or cashflow forecast with insight.



The National Westminster Bank was running a tv ad campaign at the time which claimed:  'We have a dedicated small business adviser in every branch.'  When I asked for an appointment at the local branch, the teller called across to her colleague:  "Charmaine, who's doin' small business advice this week?  Is it Mr Johnson?"  I made my excuses and left, concluding that the gulf between the promise and reality was too great.




Decades later I lived round the corner from an excellent new fish shop.  The display was good, the variety of fish was enormous and the proprietor was ready with tales of his own way of cooking different fish.  It was a family run business.  Staff were hardworking, cheerful and helpful.  They supplied local restaurants until an economic downturn reduced this side of the business and forced them to give up a second shop.  On Saturdays there were always long queues out into the street.

One Christmas they had bumper sales and customers were happy.  A few days into January, the shop suddenly closed and was replaced by an estate agent.  This small high street has declined and become less vibrant as a result.

I bumped into the owner some years later.  After expressing sadness at the loss of such a great local resource, I asked him how it had happened.  The business had a good turnover and he was determined to pay down his loans as fast as possible.  The bank called him in for an appointment and suggested they renegotiate the loan for a longer term.  He declined and explained that he could easily sustain the high level of repayments he was making.  The manager told him:  "You don't understand, we are going to renegotiate your loan."  This was clearly so that the bank could treat the fish shop as a cash cow and make as much money as possible.  He refused.  They froze his account, did not respond to his calls and forced him out of business.  He is now an employee and given up any idea of self employment.  Once again we've lost a capable entrepreneur.

Which financial institution did this?  NatWest bank.

I hadn't heard much of NatWest since the financial crisis and hadn't realised that they'd been absorbed by RBS, the Royal Bank of Scotland, one of the banks bailed out by the taxpayer.

Then I heard a FileOn4 programme 'Default by Design' about viable small businesses being driven to the wall and asset stripped.  RBS/NatWest seems to be the common thread in this story.  Instead of restructuring the loan, the latest tactic seems to be to push business owners to take out risky financial instruments (with exorbitant admin fees) to secure their loans.



The accusation is that the bank engineers a default against a loan, artificially distressing the business and forcing them into administration to profit the bank.  GRG, the fastest growing division of the bank, the Global Restructuring Group, is alleged to actively damage the value of business in order to profit from the assets.  Read an interesting history of this group here.




Lawrence Tomlinson, a business adviser for the government, has investigated the issue and written a report criticising banking practice.  RBS deny the allegations.  A law firm has been appointed to probe the bank's actions, despite conflict of interest allegations against them.

No doubt lobbying will prevent anything happening to halt this abuse and major damage to the vibrancy of our economy and entrepreneurship.

My advice to anyone planning to start their own business:  

Take care to find a really good accountant and a reliable bank.  If you make a mistake, you could lose everything.



Monday, 20 January 2014

Miliband's concertina

The concertina is a simple free reed musical instrument.  A bellows mechanism and buttons produce single notes, unlike the accordion, which produces chords from each button.

This instrument came to mind last week when hearing Ed Miliband's announcement on banks.  If he's elected, he'll break them up into smaller entities, regulate them more firmly and force them to lend more.

How interesting.




This is the same Miliband, who, along with Ed Balls, was bag carrier to former Prime Minister, Gordon Brown.  The two Eds were powerful in that Labour government and it is widely acknowledged that Balls wrote most of Brown's policy.

Gordon Brown, the Prime Minister, who famously announced in his Mansion House speech to the City of London that he would support their growth by instituting 'light touch regulation.'  Yes this is the same Gordon Brown who quadrupled the tax code for small businesses and individuals, while large corporations did sweetheart deals with the head of HMRC to pay less and small business people are bullied for every penny.

Gordon Brown also consolidated banking and the development of a massive housing and stock market rise, where people were encouraged to use equity release for personal spending.  Invesment bankers and private investment  funds developed the casino style antics that laid the economy low.

Where's the concertina?



Ed Miliband plays a simple tune.  'One Nation Labour' from a Cabinet that live in an expensive enclave (of politicians) and are part of the wealthy middle class that benefit from the sweep of the lower classes out to the far edges of the capital city.

Now he's pulling out the bellows on his instrument to reverse disastrous policies to which he contributed.  He blames the mess on the Conservative government.

He must hope the public have very short memories.

Ed Miliband's announcement that he'll use state intervention to freeze energy prices has wiped £7billion off the value of energy company shares.  No doubt this latest policy announcement will do something similar for banking shares.

If the economy keeps strengthening, Miliband will do his bit to trash it, so he can blame the government.

Ed Miliband failed to mention a new Bill put through Parliament at the end of last year.  Backbench MPs from all parties worked hard to strengthen regulations in banking and financial services to protect the public and the economy.  Miliband seems to want to take a turn on his squeezebox and reverse this effort.

Eds Miliband and Balls kept very quiet when the Co-operative Bank was in trouble because of some unwise decisions.  Ed Balls attended the opening of the Co-op Group's new headquarters and made a fulsome speech in support of the then chairman, Len Wardle.  One Nation Labour had a low interest loan from the Co-operative Bank.  The Co-operative funded both the Labour and Co-operative Party MPs (the latter is effectively the Labour Party in all but name.)  No wonder Miliband and Balls kept quiet, as they're unlikely to bite the hand that feeds a near insolvent political party.

Mr Miliband please do not preach to us about helping the British people and your great concern for our wellbeing.  No small business receives such preferential loans from the Co-op Bank and pensioners were about to lose their life savings (to fill the financial black hole) had it not been for the intervention of Mark Taber and his campaign.

You didn't answer letters about this problem (I and many others wrote several times) and did not speak about it in Parliament.

 The money is about to dry up.

Ed Miliband, your concertina is out of tune.

Monday, 9 December 2013

Co-op Bank pressured by Zionists

I reported in a recent post that the Co-op Bank has renewed its pledge to customers to retain its ethical stance.





I admire the Co-op for its boycott of goods from Jewish only settlements in Palestine.  Now the Board of Deputies and Jewish Leadership Council have requested a meeting with the Co-op's new leaders to persuade them to drop the policy.




These groups continally put pressure on the BBC to tone down any coverage of Palestinian views from the Middle East.  Mark Regev, an Israeli spokesman, is given regular air time, which is not matched by eqivalent coverage of Palestinian speakers.

Zionist pressure groups have had some success in Paliament, persuading all sides to adjust their policies to a more Israeli friendly view.





The propaganda portrays Palestinians as heavily armed terrorists, and Israelis as poor, weak, defenceless people.  Where is the coverage of Academy Award nominated '5 Broken Cameras', which shows peaceful resistance by farmers coping with increasing incursions into their farmland?

I hope the Co-op Group stands firm and resists pressure from Zionist groups to bury the truth about human rights abuses in Palestine.

I've said it before and will say it again:  'The only way is ethics'.

Friday, 29 November 2013

Co-op Bank renews its pledge

The Co-operative Bank took out full page ads in national newspapers to reassure investors of its ethical stance prior to the vote on the plan to deal with its debt.


Early bird thresholds have been met by the deadline, so enhanced consideration will be paid.  Early results show that retail bondholders and preference shareholders back the Co-operative Bank £1.5 billion Recapitalisation Plan.  Mark Taber has done a great job to achieve this.

The PR strategy probably helped the vote.  However, I think retail investors were persuaded by the offer rather than the ethics.  The Co-op Bank has admitted that it's losing retail customers.  I imagine they will have a long way to go to rebuild trust, but this is a good start.  Euan Sutherland contines to impress.

As I said in a previous post, the only way is ethics.




Tuesday, 19 November 2013

Co-op Bank & the Dog in the Manger

I have new found respect for Co-op Group Chief Executive, Euan Sutherland.





Late in the day he involved retail investment campaigner, Mark Taber, in negotiations over recapitalisation of the bank.  Mr Sutherland listened.  He co-operated.  The offer now on the table is far better than most people had expected.  Euan Sutherland is working hard to ensure that frail elderly investors have clear messages about the offer and the early bird bonus available for those who take prompt action.


Stockbrokers are still dragging their feet about communicating with retail investors and reminding those who have not taken action.  Hargreaves Lansdown are still setting the standard for proactive, clear communication.

I don't have any Co-op Bank bonds or preference shares.  I am not directly affected by the offer or the decision of customers.  I realise that Co-op Bank needs a substantial majority of retail investors to close the deal.  It seems clear that the bank may go into resolution if the offer is rejected.  Those frail elderly investors will lose everything in that case.




One other serious barrier to agreement seems to be a different class of retail investors.  These are opportunists who have bought bonds and preference shares recently at very low prices.  Some of them have said that they reject the offer and think they can get much more if they hold out and cause the deal to fail.  These investors don't depend on the income to live or pay for a roof over their head or care in later life.  This is part of a portfolio based largely on speculation and squeezing the most out of investments bought at bargain prices.

I wish Euan Sutherland the best of luck with the deal and the messy future of the Co-op Bank.  I sincerely hope that a small group of jackals don't trash the hard work done by Sutherland and Mark Taber.


What a Balls Up & Co-op Bank 2




I have written before about the resounding silence from senior Labour Party figures in relation to the recent history of the Co-op Bank.  As many people have pointed out, the Co-op Bank has extended generous loans to the Labour Party at preferential rates of interest, despite the dire financial state of our major opposition party.  I have also commented on Shadow Chancellor, Ed Balls, and his tendency to make poor decisions in government.





Today various reports have surfaced about the Labour Party and the Co-op Bank.  Ed Balls received a donation to his office last year of £50,000 arranged by the disgraced former Co-op Bank Chair, Paul Flowers.  Mr Flowers found a route into the Co-op Bank via the Labour Party, despite his lack of qualification for the post.

Ed Miliband made a speech at the Co-op Bank HQ on 9 July 2012, declaring his intention to campaign for the big banks to be broken up.  He praised the Co-op Bank as a model of integrity.  Sadly he is now getting some flak for this from financial journalists.  Ed Balls writes fulsomely about co-operative enterprise on his blog.




Ed Balls was in post as Economic Secretary to the Treasury when Paul Flowers was appointed.  Mr Balls does not seem to have scrutinised appointment procedures or regulatory oversight in the following years.  Some allege that political pressure was put on the FSA to approve of Mr Flowers' appointment.  Neither Balls nor Miliband commented on Andrew Bailey's revelations about financial problems at the Co-op Bank as early as 2011.

BBC News business editor, Robert Peston, is doing his best to shield Eds Milliband and Balls by fudging the dates and asserting that no one knew of the crisis at the Co-op Bank until the end of 2012.  It is well documented that Andrew Bailey expressed his concerns as early as mid 2011.

Other questions remain unanswered.  How did the FSA and Bank of England exercise such poor regulation of the Co-op Bank and approve key people to roles, for which they were not at all suited?

Len Wardle has resigned as Chair of the Co-op Group and Board.  There are allegations about his relationship with Ed Balls and the one off donation.  Hector Sants, who was Chief Executive of the FSA from 2007-2012, has recently resigned from Barclays Banks due to 'exhaustion and stress'.  Both of these people were involved in dealings at the Co-op Group, decisions at the Bank and poor oversight.

The Labour Party and its 2 main figures have remained silent over the Co-op Bank crisis.  They have stripped Paul Flowers of Labour Party membership.  Ed Balls was criticised by Co-op Bank savers for his part in bringing the bank to the brink of destruction.  There are calls for a return of the £50,000 donation to his office.

Ed Balls where is this One Nation Labour of which you speak?  What is your response to the prospect of pensioners losing their savings, main income and means to pay care home fees?    When will you come clean on your part in the Co-op Bank's downfall?

Thursday, 7 November 2013

Mark Taber makes progress with Co-op Bank

If you, your family or friends hold retail investments with Co-op Bank (such as bonds and preference shares), then you need to get information about the offer made to customers this week.  Here is the announcement made by Co-op Group Chief Executive, Euan Sutherland, on 4 November 2013.


Why does this matter?

If you vote to accept the offer and submit your forms promptly, you will receive a higher reward than those who leave it to the last moment.  If you're late, you'll miss the early bird bonus.

My broking firm will sort it for me, so  why do I need to worry?

Many broking firms have been slow on the uptake, not organised the paperwork and have given out erroneous information.  They need a firm push from customers to spur them into action.***

Here is Mark Taber's potted summary of the offer.



Mark Taber has a track record of supporting distressed retail investors.  In particular he has worked hard for pensioners who rely on income from bonds and preference shares to pay for their care home fees.  The Co-op Bank did not include this group in their original discussions.  Mark Taber has changed their minds by mounting an effective campaign to publicise the injustices and poor business practices of the bank and lax oversight by the regulators.

The Prime Minister, the Chancellor of the Exchequer and their Opposition Counterparts did not take action.  Other politicians, such as Jesse Norman, worked hard to interrogate the bankers and regulators, which helped move us to the current offer.

Mark has run campaigns to help customers of other banks including the Bank of Ireland.  He holds no retail investments in Co-op Bank and has worked voluntarily to achieve an astonishingly positive outcome.  His website accepts donations to help him survive whilst working so hard for others.

Thank you Mark Taber.





*** Update on stockbrokers:  I understand that Hargreaves Lansdown are the star performers with regards to the Co-op Bank offer (on 12/11/2013).   'They have produced a clear and easy to understand corporate action notice and agreed to chase up clients who have not acted' (Mark Taber).  They have set the benchmark by which other stockbrokers will be judged (currently performing much less well).

Stephen Fitzpatrick understands the power of working with integrity, when all around you others are not.  It's good for sustainable business.  If you treat people fairly, more customers will find you.  If you don't, like the Co-op Bank when they first announced the need to bridge the funding gap, customers will leave you.




Saturday, 19 October 2013

The Co-op Bank and the long grass

'If an issue or problem is kicked into the long grass, it is pushed aside and hidden in the hope that it will be forgotten or ignored'.



Origin:  'kick it into the long grass' is golf-derived, essentially describing a form of cheating:  a player whose ball lands in the rough so as to be unplayable without adding multiple strokes to the hole can cheat by kicking the ball out-of-bounds into the really long grass and take a one-stroke penalty for a lost ball.



This is the story of elderly people, who worked hard, built up savings and then invested with a traditional institution they trusted, the Co-operative Bank.  They shop with the co-op, buy insurance with them, travel with them and have probably bought a funeral plan with the same company, ie the Co-operative Group.

The bank built up a £1.5bn debt through maladministration.  Part of this occurred when the Co-op Bank merged with Britannia Building Society, relying on 'due diligence' by accountancy firm KPMG, and found they'd bought a turkey.  Another loss was incurred in a failed attempt to buy branches of Lloyds bank, (an enforced sale by the government).  This was Project Verde.  TSB has now come back from the dead to run the branches as an independent bank.

Both the Co-op Group and Co-op Bank concealed the level of debt from retail investors until June 2013, after the AGM.  The regulator also concealed the problem.  This created a false market in retail investments.



I could have told the government, regulators and the Co-op Bank that it would end in tears.  If the idea was to create an enlarged bank on a par with the big boys, then something was missing.  If you visit a branch of the Co-op Bank today, you'll find they are still inputting data from cheques manually, rather than swiping the digital codes as their competitors do.  That's a non starter for a grown up bank.  One former executive reports that the Co-op Bank consistently refused to agree investment in major IT renewal.



The Co-operative Group claims to be independent of the bank and have no responsibility to bail it out, as it is not a financial holding company.  Strangely the Co-op Group Chief Executive, Euan Sutherland, seemed to be steering the bank through capital appraisal, recapitalisation plan and negotiations with the regulator culminating in similar announcements from both on 14 June 2013.  Mr Sutherland was hastily co-opted onto the bank's board as a non-executive director some time later.  The regulator told Co-op retail customers 'You're on your own'.



The big plan was outlined as a way to take a load of money off retail investors, who seemed to be a bunch of casino gambling customers in the eyes of the Co-op senior management.   Co-op bank executives seemed happy to lend money at low rates to a near bankrupt organisation, the Labour Party, while planning to fleece loyal retail customers of their hard earned life savings.  Representations were made to the bank, the regulator and the Co-op Group but fell on deaf ears until commercial investors (hedge fund managers) moved in for the kill.

Retail investors are still not invited to any of the talks on recapitalisation.  Mark Taber, of the action group, called for a Hardship Fund to be set up.  It seems as if this may happen without involving retail customers.  The idea is to split retail investors into hardship/non-hardship cases, with someone acting as God and making life changing decisions.



This reminds me of the case of Equitable Life.  People were encouraged to manage their own investments and pensions.  Rumours developed that Equitable Life was in big financial trouble.  A statement was made in Parliament that all was well.  Insiders allege that politicians extracted their investments from the company.  Ordinary investors waited in vain for years for compensations, many dying without redress in the interim.  They were characterised as wealthy people who didn't need the money.  I still meet Equitable Life investors who are in hardship as a result of the failure of the company and financial oversight by government and the regulator.

One member of the regulatory staff, Andrew Bailey, raised concerns as early as mid 2011, but was ignored.  The Bank of England redacted paragraphs from its report, that would reveal the state of the banks finances, leaving retail investors in the dark.  There is some indication that government pressure led to regulatory failure to protect customers.



Lord Myners, Jess Norman MP and colleagues have worked hard to interrogate regulators and senior figures in the Co-op Bank and Co-operative Group in the House of Commons Treasury Committee.

Ed Miliband, Ed Balls and Labour MPs have been silent about the Co-op Bank and not responded to queries from constituents.  The preferential Co-op Bank loan to them at a time of fragile party finances seems to have caused them to forget core party principles.  Labour are focusing on press regulation and utility bills and ignoring elderly people about to lose their life savings.

What's the long grass?


Mark Taber has outlined this, with supporting evidence, in his open letter to Sajid Javid.


HM Treasury states that this is a private matter between Co-op bank and its bondholders.  It does not intend to use its powers to investigate the actions of the regulator.

The Bank of England concealed information from the public.  The regulator colluded with the bank in concealing the capital shortfall for 2 years.  The regulator authorities ignored the warnings of one of its own senior staff.

Is this a private matter between the bank and its bondholders?

The FCA (regulator) has taken no action to investigate the Co-op Group or Co-op Bank.

Mr Wardle misled a shareholder's meeting in May 2013.  Mr Sutherland exercised powers to which he was not legally entitled, determing policy for a bank in which he had no position.  Bank and Co-op Group executives overreached themselves, ignoring the warnings of peers, plunging the bank into huge financial losses.

Is this not a matter to be investigated by the current regulator?

HM Treasury is referring bondholders to the Co-op Group's own 'independent inquiry.'

Commentators allege that Project Verde was instigated by senior people in government, who put pressure on the bank and the regulator to carry on despite warnings about the state of Co-op Bank finances and capacity.

Is pressure being put on HM Treasury to deflect attention away from government?

The Co-operative Group has commissioned an 'independent inquiry'.  This has no status or powers and does not include retail investors as stakeholders.  The remit does not include investigations into the Co-op's dealing with the regulators, nor the false market established by concealing information from the public.


In the UK we are familiar with inquiries as a great way of showing that something is being done.  Questions can be batted away with 'Let's wait for the results of the inquiry', which may take years.  The heat is off and those involved in dodgy dealing can escape scrutiny.






MP Sajid Javid is a new appointment to the Treasury.  He is an able young man, who is grappling with the issues surrounding the Co-op Bank.  Much rests on his ability to go beyond strict compliance.  Many hope for great things from him.  I reserve judgement.



Update:  Many thanks to Mark Taber for an interesting piece of news.

Euan Sutherland, Group Chief Executive, has made an announcement that includes the words 'small investors'.  Now we don't know exactly what he means by this term, but it is a tiny step forward in a hard fight to accept liability for maladministration and avoid fleecing the unwary.

Further update:  US Hedge Funds have driven a hard bargain in the re-financing deal.  The Co-operative Group say they will still be the largest overall shareholder with a 30% stake.  They won't control the bank.  In my experience of other US mergers/take-overs/re-financing deals, the original owners find it tough to deal with the US incomers.  In my experience as a retail customer of such organisations, the US parent companies tend to run the organisation into the ground and extract as much profit as possible for little beneficial input.  There are probably exceptions, but I am not optimistic about the future of the Co-op Bank for customers.

Nor is another blogger, who has written about the interesting history of the 2 Hedge Funds now controlling Co-op Bank:

'But make no mistake, Sutherland and his fellow Board members will be on a very short leash. They must return the Co-Op Bank to profitability within a very short time - otherwise the hedge funds are likely to turn nasty. They will not hesitate to asset-strip the Co-Op Bank if the management fails to meet the profitability targets that they expect. And as between them they DO have a controlling stake, they can unquestionably do this. Sutherland's statement was made with a gun to his head.'