When I work with teams and teach traditional personality inventories I challenge them to go beyond labelling each other.
How can knowledge of personality types help you communicate more effectively with colleagues, bosses and customers?
Myers Briggs Type Indicator distinguishes between different ways of making decisions: Thinking - based on facts and logic versus Feeling - based on values.
Here are 2 public information videos about wearing seat belts. The first one alerts motorists and passengers to the risks of not wearing rear seat belts. In this case, the passenger may 'kill' the driver.
A more recent commercial encourages male drivers to think about their families and a future life together as a reason to 'belt up' or embrace life.
Both films may shock the viewer, but the first is informative and the second one emphasises values.
LAB profiling also points out that the first film motivates people to move away from the negative (ie death), whereas the second encourages people to go toward the positive (ie life with loved ones). Not all of us are motivated by the same thing and slanting adverts to focus on catastrophe doesn't necessarily engage those who are more focussed on goals than risks.
In MBTI this roughly correlates to the Extraverion/Introversion scale, but NLP expresses preferences in clearer terms.
Showing posts with label Psychometric tests. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychometric tests. Show all posts
Monday, 11 April 2011
The 'So what?' test
Reflecting on inventories
I'm not a big fan of using standard psychometric tests in recruitment and selection.
One way I like to use personality inventories is in coaching, as a way to help show someone how well they have developed.
For example, managers often come to me because they are overwhelmed with stress and struggle to keep going in the job. After we've worked together for a while and focussed on ways of reducing the pressure, shifting mindsets, delegating and managing self and others better, it's useful to sit back and reflect.
What aspects of their personality may have contributed to the problem?
Using NEO five factor inventory, we can focus on a few dimensions that may have contributed to stress in the past, but which, with lower scores, are more manageable.
High Conscientiousness, where a manager may work to such high standards that they feel responsible for everything, coupled with High Agreeableness, where a manager may be reluctant to discipline staff and keen to avoid conflict at all costs, can increase pressure on the individual. When the manager has High Sensitivity and worries about things going wrong or perceived criticism from superiors or subordinates, it may take very little for this person to crack under the strain.
By introducing these concepts when things are improving, the manager may feel much less defensive about the dimensions and relevant descriptions, but recognise the elements that have caused trouble. These can then be used as a personal tracking system to help maintain pressure at a safe and healthy level.
One way I like to use personality inventories is in coaching, as a way to help show someone how well they have developed.
For example, managers often come to me because they are overwhelmed with stress and struggle to keep going in the job. After we've worked together for a while and focussed on ways of reducing the pressure, shifting mindsets, delegating and managing self and others better, it's useful to sit back and reflect.
What aspects of their personality may have contributed to the problem?
Using NEO five factor inventory, we can focus on a few dimensions that may have contributed to stress in the past, but which, with lower scores, are more manageable.
High Conscientiousness, where a manager may work to such high standards that they feel responsible for everything, coupled with High Agreeableness, where a manager may be reluctant to discipline staff and keen to avoid conflict at all costs, can increase pressure on the individual. When the manager has High Sensitivity and worries about things going wrong or perceived criticism from superiors or subordinates, it may take very little for this person to crack under the strain.
By introducing these concepts when things are improving, the manager may feel much less defensive about the dimensions and relevant descriptions, but recognise the elements that have caused trouble. These can then be used as a personal tracking system to help maintain pressure at a safe and healthy level.
Labels:
Development area,
Personality,
Psychometric tests,
reflection
Saturday, 9 April 2011
The customer journey
People who buy products or use services are a pesky lot and increasingly unpredictable.
Organisations may map the customer journey for a variety of purposes. Sometimes the aim is to reduce it to a series of steps in marketing to which specific monetary value can be assigned.
Another way of considering the progression of the customer through these contact points is to review how well the shop window reflects the culture and public statements of the organisation. Both Chris Argyris and Donald Schon have written about congruence and gaps between theory espoused and theory in use. Yesterday I sat in a waiting room reading a poster that said: 'Our aim is perfection, excellence is tolerated'. There were damp patches on the ceiling, mistakes had been made in my customer record, which no one was willing to correct and I waited an hour and a half to be seen. Who defines perfection and excellence?
Organisations may hire mystery shoppers or be visited by anonymous critics or inspectors, depending on their sector. The aim is to check that front line staff are maintaining standards of customer service. Little thought seems to be given to another category of potential customer, the job candidate.
I've worked with managers who believe they must use psychometric inventories in their selection process because other organisations do so. Some use assessment centres with a battery of tests to present a professional image. As a candidate I've rarely seen tests applied as specified in the manual. Many managers seem to have no understanding of the instrument and refer to the company pschologist or external consultant who processed the results. More often the results of tests are set aside or mislaid, giving a bad impression of the organisation and how managers value the time and effort of job candidates.
I've known high calibre HR staff who are adept at using psychometric tests and following them up with an interview to review the results and amend any errors. In my experience these are the exception.
When clients ask for help with their recruitment and selection process I ask them to identify the purpose of tests. Are there specific aspects of the job that a particular inventory might help them to select against?
I tend to recommend simpler tests than many on the market, so that managers understand and can apply them with confidence. Alternatively I suggest that they hire me to screen candidates based on specific aspects of job fit. In the latter case I use LAB Profiling, because candidates learn as much about themselves and the type of job that would suit them as the organisation learns about them. The interview avoids jargon and draws on real work examples.
For example, I've helped small business owners avoid hiring office managers who don't enjoy following standard procedures and tend to reduce efficiency and profitability by constantly tinkering with core processes.
In the current economic climate managers who advertise job vacancies may be overwhelmed with the number of applications. Tests or qualifications may be used as a way to reduce the number of candidates. Unfortunately neither seem to ensure the selection of ideal people unless work has been done to define the gap that an individual may fill in a team.
Organisations may map the customer journey for a variety of purposes. Sometimes the aim is to reduce it to a series of steps in marketing to which specific monetary value can be assigned.
Another way of considering the progression of the customer through these contact points is to review how well the shop window reflects the culture and public statements of the organisation. Both Chris Argyris and Donald Schon have written about congruence and gaps between theory espoused and theory in use. Yesterday I sat in a waiting room reading a poster that said: 'Our aim is perfection, excellence is tolerated'. There were damp patches on the ceiling, mistakes had been made in my customer record, which no one was willing to correct and I waited an hour and a half to be seen. Who defines perfection and excellence?
Organisations may hire mystery shoppers or be visited by anonymous critics or inspectors, depending on their sector. The aim is to check that front line staff are maintaining standards of customer service. Little thought seems to be given to another category of potential customer, the job candidate.
I've worked with managers who believe they must use psychometric inventories in their selection process because other organisations do so. Some use assessment centres with a battery of tests to present a professional image. As a candidate I've rarely seen tests applied as specified in the manual. Many managers seem to have no understanding of the instrument and refer to the company pschologist or external consultant who processed the results. More often the results of tests are set aside or mislaid, giving a bad impression of the organisation and how managers value the time and effort of job candidates.
I've known high calibre HR staff who are adept at using psychometric tests and following them up with an interview to review the results and amend any errors. In my experience these are the exception.
When clients ask for help with their recruitment and selection process I ask them to identify the purpose of tests. Are there specific aspects of the job that a particular inventory might help them to select against?
I tend to recommend simpler tests than many on the market, so that managers understand and can apply them with confidence. Alternatively I suggest that they hire me to screen candidates based on specific aspects of job fit. In the latter case I use LAB Profiling, because candidates learn as much about themselves and the type of job that would suit them as the organisation learns about them. The interview avoids jargon and draws on real work examples.
For example, I've helped small business owners avoid hiring office managers who don't enjoy following standard procedures and tend to reduce efficiency and profitability by constantly tinkering with core processes.
In the current economic climate managers who advertise job vacancies may be overwhelmed with the number of applications. Tests or qualifications may be used as a way to reduce the number of candidates. Unfortunately neither seem to ensure the selection of ideal people unless work has been done to define the gap that an individual may fill in a team.
Friday, 12 November 2010
Milton Erickson's early career
Milton Erickson was a qualified doctor and psychologist. NLP made him famous as a hypnotherapist, but only drew on experience of him as an 70+ year old teacher in a wheelchair (disabled by post polio syndrome).
He worked for a time in a secure mental hospital. He tackled difficult cases and made dramatic breakthroughs using unorthodox approaches. Erickson believed in utilising symptoms rather than suppressing them.
One patient was seen as a problem because he stood around staring into space with his elbow sticking out. Erickson studied the setting and put the man into a blue overall and encouraged him to rest his elbow on a broom. The patient shifted from 'problem' to 'janitor' and was seen as a normal fixture in corridors.
Another patient believed he was Jesus Christ. Erickson avoided debating this idea. He approached the man and said "I understand you are a carpenter. I'd appreciate your help in repairing the staff tennis court nets, as the doctors need more exercise." The patient shifted into the role of handyman in the hospital.
In my experience, many managers try to suppress symptoms rather than utilise them. "How can I offload this person (with the wrong psychological profile)" is more common than "How can I best utilise his/her strengths?"
Not all sales people need to be action oriented, aggressive pathfinders. That's fine in a new market. However a mature, saturated market, would benefit from the detail oriented, methodical worker, who could identify the range of small opportunities to increase sales.
Variety in a team increases scope for the range of projects tackled, as long as we manage the differences.
He worked for a time in a secure mental hospital. He tackled difficult cases and made dramatic breakthroughs using unorthodox approaches. Erickson believed in utilising symptoms rather than suppressing them.
One patient was seen as a problem because he stood around staring into space with his elbow sticking out. Erickson studied the setting and put the man into a blue overall and encouraged him to rest his elbow on a broom. The patient shifted from 'problem' to 'janitor' and was seen as a normal fixture in corridors.
Another patient believed he was Jesus Christ. Erickson avoided debating this idea. He approached the man and said "I understand you are a carpenter. I'd appreciate your help in repairing the staff tennis court nets, as the doctors need more exercise." The patient shifted into the role of handyman in the hospital.
In my experience, many managers try to suppress symptoms rather than utilise them. "How can I offload this person (with the wrong psychological profile)" is more common than "How can I best utilise his/her strengths?"
Not all sales people need to be action oriented, aggressive pathfinders. That's fine in a new market. However a mature, saturated market, would benefit from the detail oriented, methodical worker, who could identify the range of small opportunities to increase sales.
Variety in a team increases scope for the range of projects tackled, as long as we manage the differences.
Richard Feynman's dad
Melville Feynman was a little known businessman. He made a major contribution to physics, the development of the atomic bomb, science teaching and popularising physics.
How?
When all the other dads were teaching their kids "That's the Lesser Spotted Winzelschmurter", Melville encouraged his son to observe what this curious creature did, how it survived and thrived.
He also trained his son to translate facts into domestic terms, by answering the question "What does that mean in real terms?". Melville would take the details given of the height of an object and tell Richard "That means this was as high as 3 copies of our house stacked on top of each other." His Nobel prize winning son found himself making this translation as a natural reflex.
I'm a fan of Melville because he discouraged the practice of labelling and switching off brain. Above all he was a great user of the 'So what?' question.
What a pity Melville was just a closet scientist and didn't turn his attention to personality, temperament and cognitive style. He might have encouraged us to think about the results of personality inventories. If he had, we might not keep tripping over the jargon of inventories. We'd also have a clearer idea of how the results show up in our lives.
Above all, we'd focus more on how to cope with individual differences and work to our strengths.
How?
When all the other dads were teaching their kids "That's the Lesser Spotted Winzelschmurter", Melville encouraged his son to observe what this curious creature did, how it survived and thrived.
He also trained his son to translate facts into domestic terms, by answering the question "What does that mean in real terms?". Melville would take the details given of the height of an object and tell Richard "That means this was as high as 3 copies of our house stacked on top of each other." His Nobel prize winning son found himself making this translation as a natural reflex.
I'm a fan of Melville because he discouraged the practice of labelling and switching off brain. Above all he was a great user of the 'So what?' question.
What a pity Melville was just a closet scientist and didn't turn his attention to personality, temperament and cognitive style. He might have encouraged us to think about the results of personality inventories. If he had, we might not keep tripping over the jargon of inventories. We'd also have a clearer idea of how the results show up in our lives.
Above all, we'd focus more on how to cope with individual differences and work to our strengths.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)