Showing posts with label Style. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Style. Show all posts

Saturday, 31 March 2012

Introversion in a world of Prozac

Peter D Kramer challenged Western societies and the increasing trend to view extraversion as the norm and introversion as problematic. His book 'Listening to Prozac' raised issues about cosmetic pharmacology and the urge to homogenise personalities in the modern world.

Susan Cain gives a TED talk from the perspective of a successful introvert and argues the case for accepting and valuing introversion in the workplace.

Tuesday, 29 November 2011

Sharing my secrets

Bruce Muzik talks about his experience of challenging perceptions and prejudices he absorbed from birth in Apartheid South Africa. Here's how he took off those distorting lenses and experienced his native country in a new way.

It started by sharing his terrible secret:



He gives a good insight into how generalisations about other cultures and communities arise and are perpetuated.

His main purpose is in motivating others to take steps to remove numbness and increase aliveness.

In management studies we consider various ways in which people interact and cooperate. There are psychometric instruments to help us distinguish personality and style differences. Emotional intelligence guides us in ways to manage ourselves and our interactions with others. Team roles enable us to consider various functions that have to be fulfilled in completing a project and the distribution across members of the group engaged in the work.

Bruce Muzik encourages us to come back to ourselves and work on the inner kinks that block energy and a full sense of aliveness. I don't think he's encouraging people to be naive and blunder into the boss's office with the words 'I hate you and all you stand for'. He does suggest ways that might improve working relationships and trust.

One of his coaching examples might shed some light on the mysterious suicide of Welsh football manager, Gary Speed, who did not seem depressed and had no major conflicts with family and friends in the days before he died. Perhaps he nursed a secret that became unbearable?

Tuesday, 15 November 2011

Me and my shadow


As I see it, the ultimate purpose of taking psychological inventories and analysing our style is to improve how we relate to other people. Merely learning to label ourselves and other people adds little to the sum of human knowledge.


Daniel Goleman's work on emotional and other non-standard forms of intelligence encourages us to distinguish between awareness and management of self and relationship with others. Our personal style shows up in patterns that may or may not blend well with others and have a positive impact on communication and relationships.


Jung's archetypes, the inspiration for work on modern style inventories, included the notion that we come to terms with some of our weaker dimensions as we go through life. He noted that the weakest trait was our shadow side and likely to rise up and bite us on the backside at awkward moments in life. If we don't recognise the shadow, develop self awareness and do something about it, we may be stuck with patterns that are destructive and don't serve us well. The intention is not to get us to change personality, but work to our strengths. If we have a wider choice of responses and behaviours, we may defuse unnecessary conflict and misunderstandings.

My colleague, Kieran Duignan, is breaking new ground with what he calls Behavioural Diplomacy, building on the work of Scott Benjamin. He has developed a questionnaire (to be used with clients and their close network) to illuminate those dark corners. His portrait of behaviour patterns may not make comfortable reading to clients. With time and changing circumstances, client motivation may shift and bring them to the table ready to work on managing themselves and relationships differently. Mergers and acquisitions with their job insecurity or changing demands from new management can be one catalyst for a shift in motivation.


Richard Fisch, co-author of a seminal book on change, who died last month, founded the Brief Therapy Centre at MRI in Palo Alto California. He took a revolutionary approach to mental health research, focussing on the problem that the client was most concerned about rather than telling the client what he believed was wrong with them (current practice in psychology at the time.) This solved problems of 'resistance' or lack of motivation for change, as sessions dealt with major concerns brought by the client. Reading some of Fisch's case examples, there are some clear shadows or areas that don't work in his client's dealings with others, of which they seem totally unaware. Fisch is able to frame them as skill deficits and work successfully with the client to change patterns in the service of their desired goal.


In discussion with Kieran Duignan on his work on Behavioural Diplomacy, I reflected on my experience in some organisations where senior male managers with sub-optimal patterns sometimes appoint a woman in a floating role to act as a buffer between them and humanoids. The senior managers showed minimal interest or awareness in their own style, but felt the need for someone to deal with what they regard as trivial, routine and time consuming people issues.

Many years ago I talked to the Managing Director of a major UK agency supplying temporary secretarial staff to offices around the country. His partner, an Executive Secretary, was launching a work-to-rule of people in her position to campaign for better recognition and reward for their services. Thus, for example, when the chief executive told her to respond to a client requesting a meeting "Tell him to p*ss off, I'm going to play golf", she would do exactly that, rather than relaying a more diplomatic message to the caller.

Perhaps the Executive Secretary of decades ago has transformed into non-Board roles such as Strategy Consultant or Development Analyst, but always held by women. Maybe senior women who are criticised for being too aggressive or lacking sufficient people skills are those who don't have a buffer to deal with those pesky humanoids.

Thursday, 23 June 2011

21st century Bounderby


Charles Dickens wrote novels in the 19th century. He was critical of industrialisation driven by Utilitarianism and greed. In his novels, working people were treated as expendable machines and pushed to the limit.


We recall these descriptions when campaigning against exploitation of workers in the developing world manufacturing clothes for the West by Nike, Primark and Adidas or campaigns by migrant workers in the USA against human trafficking.


In the 1950s manufacturing was transformed by the work of Frederick Taylor using time and motion studies as part of scientific management. Processes were reduced to simple, cost effective movements and overlooked motivation and effort available when people have some control over their work. Companies in the USA were forced to reform manufacturing methods, particularly in the automotive industry in Detroit, when Japan outstripped them in the marketplace with superior quality (though it didn't save industrial Detroit).


Production line processes were replaced by work groups, where staff became responsible for the total building of a car rather than a single repetitive action. Employment by a factory implied that an individual had sold his soul to the company.

The USA has produced entrepreneurs and academics who have revolutionised our thinking about management and leadership. Many of them are represented in this blog and in the Open University Business School MBA programme.

My colleagues and I have become aware of a change in organisations over the last decade. Students and clients tell me their experience of working for equity finance companies or American owned UK companies and some of it reminds me of Dickens. For example, a small company taken over by an American firm may undergo a process of 'sterilisation' where all personal effects and non standard elements are removed from the office (from the way people dress to family photos on their desks.) Others tell me of brief chats over coffee about a night out ending with a drink in the pub, only to be hauled into a meeting with management to investigate possible alcohol addiction. Non work chatter is discouraged. Contracts may be changed to require long days, minimal holidays and weekend working as standard.


Rule by fear seems to be another feature of leadership in such companies. Focus on targets and frequent arbitrary sacking of under performing staff generates a stressful climate that does not foster initiative, enthusiasm, fresh ideas and good will. Little attention seems to be paid to human complexity and motivation and 60 years of management and organisational research may have been wasted. In some cases attempted suicides amongst staff are high.

Basic management tasks, such as performance management, may be poorly handled in these companies. There is scant evidence that harsh treatment and directive management styles lead to greater profitability or fewer mistakes. One production manager told me that the firm was losing money on a par with setting fire to a Ferrari every couple of months, despite reducing manufacturing processes to an 'idiot proof' simplicity. If you reduce the capacity to think and make decisions at work, then it's likely that people will respond by switching off their brains.

Companies that follow this trend rely on high unemployment, reducing wages and conditions across many sectors and increasing threats to the financial system from the prospect of defaults by Greece, Ireland and other countries.

We are part of a global economy and competition comes from across the world, with low waged countries facing fewer regulations competing for market share.

This doesn't justify a retrograde step towards Taylorism and directive management styles. Semco survived tough times in Brazil and is a thriving company. Ricardo Semler holds firmly to the idea of fostering a creative work climate and empowering staff to gain the best from them. 'The Why of Work' presents some telling statistics about the benefits of treating staff well.


When I coach managers who are struggling to perform well under stress, I discourage them from fleeing the current job immediately. If we can broaden their skills to delegate, manage and lead more effectively, boosting resilience and stress management techniques, then they can stay in a familiar role and thrive.

If this is not possible, I take them by the scruff of the neck to prevent them from taking the first new job offer that arrives. Avoid jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire. Part of my role is to shift their mindset in approaching interviews and job selection. My client is not a beggar offering their body and soul for the chance of work. Job seeking is much more like matchmaking, where the applicant must research whether the organisation is a good fit for their style and skills, not just allowing the company to decide whether or not to offer the job to them.

Friday, 26 November 2010

Taunting the tiger

In 2006 Zinedine Zidane was sent off in the 110th minute of a world cup final against Italy for head butting Marco Materazzi.  Zidane was a role model for Algerians in France and helped soften the anti-Algerian feeling widespread in France at the time.  It was Zizzie's last international match, as he had announced his retirement from the game.  France lost 5-3 and a brilliant footballing career ended in shame.




How did this happen?

Allegedly Zidane responded with anger to an allegation by Materazzi that his sister earned her living in a horizontal position.

Gamesmanship is common in sports.  Female tennis players develop a loud grunting style at Wimbledon to put opponents off their stroke.  Muhammad Ali was famous for loud and extravagant pre-fight predictions of when and how he would obliterate his opponents, calculated to intimidate them.

Zidane was targeted by someone who understood his weak spots and how to exploit them.

Daniel Goleman writes about Emotional Intelligence and illuminates my example with a quadrant:  Self, Other:  Awareness, Management.

The first challenge is to be aware of our emotional states and what contributes to them (or triggers them).  The second task if to manage our emotional states, so that we can be effective and achieve our goals in a particular situation without getting derailed by a strong emotion.

The next level involves awareness of other people's emotional states, which isn't easy.  We learn to read faces, posture, skin tone, breathing and other physical signs of emotions, as well as what people do and do not say.  Once we've identified them we can begin to manage other people's emotional states.  Our voice tone, facial expression, gestures, position in relation to others and the content of what we say can all have an influence on other people's emotional states.

In my example, Zidane was playing in a match that had big significance for him.  He'd done well up to this point and the Italians could not beat him physically, but chose to attack mentally.  Zidane was caught off guard and his anger boiled over before he realised it.   Instead of walking away, retaliating with a comment or approaching the referee, he attacked his opponent, earning him a red card.  Materazzi had a strong grasp of emotional intelligence and used it for his own benefit, but at the cost of Zidane's reputation.  A quietly delivered snide comment was like throwing a lighted match into a barrel of petrol:  it exploded.

I've coached customer service personnel who struggle to deal with irate customers by phone. It may be wearing to handle such calls many times a day, but skills in Goleman's quadrant can make the process easier and more pleasant for both parties to the call.  This becomes tougher where management set big targets and the context is debt collection.

Managers come to me with a particular weak spot that often relates to managing the performance of staff with a problem.  Crying women may put a male manager off disciplining someone for poor performance.  A drink problem may distract a manager from dealing with punctuality or sloppy record keeping.  Compassion can threaten the health and safety of colleagues in certain contexts.  In these examples awareness and management of their own emotional states is the key to progress.

Gamesmanship can be defeated, but it needs preparation and practice.  The world cup final is not the place to begin to develop emotional intelligence.

Friday, 12 November 2010

Ipomoea

Ipomoea is the largest genus in the flowering plant family Convolvulaceae with over 500 species.  Most of them are known as morning glory.  They are colourful, climb up supports and seek out light.  Their roots are easy to dig or pull out and they tend to die off at the end of the summer after setting seed.  The trumpet like flowers open to the sun and close at other times.

Their cousins of the genus Calystegia look similar, but don't behave so well.  Bindweed is the most familiar in this group.  It climbs over anything and binds to the point of strangling other plants.  The roots are invasive and resemble underground spaghetti (made of strong flex).  The only way to eradicate bindweed is to dig out every last bit of root, or it will return and, once again, make an attempt at world domination.

I think of these 2 cousins when people ask me how far it's possible to change personality.

I've seen introverts, who try to fade into the wallpaper, grow in confidence and develop skills in small talk and public speaking.  I've never seen introverts shift from enjoying 1:1 friendships and conversations to relishing hanging out with a group and sharing light exchanges with a bunch of people at the same time.

I don't think elephants turn into tigers, or giraffes into wildebeestes.  We can shift along the spectrum and expand our range, but not shift into another personality type altogether.

Plants may become more well behaved and less aggressive in style.  The morning glory doesn't turn into a short, non climbing plant, with bushy spikes and fruit.  Bindweed will always have its characteristic flowers, even if becomes more domestic and less delinquent.

Richard Feynman's dad

Melville Feynman was a little known businessman.  He made a major contribution to physics, the development of the atomic bomb, science teaching and popularising physics.

How?

When all the other dads were teaching their kids "That's the Lesser Spotted Winzelschmurter", Melville encouraged his son to observe what this curious creature did, how it survived and thrived.

He also trained his son to translate facts into domestic terms, by answering the question "What does that mean in real terms?".  Melville would take the details given of the height of an object and tell Richard "That means this was as high as 3 copies of our house stacked on top of each other."  His Nobel prize winning son found himself making this translation as a natural reflex.



I'm a fan of Melville because he discouraged the practice of labelling and switching off brain.  Above all he was a great user of the 'So what?' question.  

What a pity Melville was just a closet scientist and didn't turn his attention to personality, temperament and cognitive style.  He might have encouraged us to think about the results of personality inventories.  If he had, we might not keep tripping over the jargon of inventories.  We'd also have a clearer idea of how the results show up in our lives.

Above all, we'd focus more on how to cope with individual differences and work to our strengths.